VS · same cedar family, different footprint
Bellerose XL vs Poppy Greenhouse
Bellerose XL vs Poppy greenhouse: 143 vs 77 sq ft cedar+PC kits, 9,200 vs 4,200 lb snow load. Specs, who each is for, verdict.
The Backyard Discovery Bellerose XL (13 × 11 ft, 143 sq ft, cedar wood, polycarbonate, 9,200 lb snow load, 100 mph wind, 5-year warranty) versus the Backyard Discovery Poppy 11' × 7' (77 sq ft, cedar wood, 4-wall polycarbonate, 4,200 lb snow load, 100 mph wind, 5-year warranty). Same brand, same cedar-and-polycarbonate walk-in kit family. The Bellerose XL adds 66 sq ft and a higher published snow load. Peak height is not published for either.
Specifications
Both kits are premium cedar walk-ins with included exhaust fan, windows, hose hook-ups, PowerPort, and staging shelves. The catalog delta is footprint and snow-load figure, not materials class.
The two kits
Backyard Discovery Bellerose XL 13' x 11' Cedar Wood and Polycarbonate Walk-in Greenhouse Kit with Pergola, Exhaust Fan, Windows, Hose Hook-Ups, PowerPort, Staging Shelves for Outdoor Gardening
Polycarbonate greenhouse · 13 × 11 ft
Backyard Discovery Poppy 11' x 7' Cedar Wood and Polycarbonate Walk-In Greenhouse Kit with Exhaust Fan, Windows, Hose Hook-Ups, PowerPort, Staging Shelves, Plant Hooks for Year-Round Outdoor Gardening
Greenhouse · 11 × 7 ft
Who should buy the Bellerose XL
Pick the Bellerose XL when you can site a 13 × 11 ft (143 sq ft) cedar kit and want the higher 9,200 lb snow-load rating plus the pergola roofline.
- 143 sq ft versus 77 sq ft on the Poppy
- 9,200 lb snow load versus 4,200 lb
- Cedar frame with pergola roofline; exhaust fan, windows, and staging shelves included
- Tagged for permanent, premium garden installs
Who should buy the Poppy
Pick the Poppy when an 11 × 7 ft (77 sq ft) cedar kit is the yard fit and you still want the same accessory pack: exhaust fan, windows, hose hook-ups, PowerPort, staging shelves, and plant hooks.
- Smaller 11 × 7 ft footprint for tighter yards
- 4-wall polycarbonate recorded (Bellerose XL mm not published)
- Same 100 mph wind rating and 5-year warranty class
- Same included ventilation and staging hardware family
What could be better on both
- Peak height is not published for either kit
- Premium price — both need a proper base
- Heavy cedar builds are multi-day, multi-person jobs
Frequently asked questions
Frequently asked questions
The Bellerose XL is 13 × 11 ft (143 sq ft). The Poppy is 11 × 7 ft (77 sq ft). That is 66 extra square feet on the Bellerose XL. Peak height is not published for either.
Yes. Both are Backyard Discovery cedar-wood walk-in kits with polycarbonate glazing. The Poppy catalog records 4-wall polycarbonate; Bellerose XL glazing thickness is not published.
The Bellerose XL records a 9,200 lb snow load. The Poppy records a 4,200 lb snow load. Both list a 100 mph wind rating and a 5-year warranty.
Buy the Poppy when an 11 × 7 ft (77 sq ft) cedar kit fits the yard and you still want the exhaust fan, windows, hose hook-ups, PowerPort, and staging shelves. Buy the Bellerose XL when you need 143 sq ft and the higher 9,200 lb snow-load figure.
The data-driven pair page is /compare/1-vs-118.
Open the live comparison
Open the compare workbench